5034 257th Street Myakka Florida | Home for Sale
To schedule a showing of 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida, Call David Shippey at 863-521-4517 TODAY!
Myakka, FL 34251
- 6Beds
- 4.00Total Baths
- 4 Full, 0 HalfBaths
- 3,304SqFt
- 1995Year Built
- 5.00Acres
- MLS# A4655682
- Residential
- SingleFamilyResidence
- Active
- Approx Time on Market1 month, 9 days
- Area34251 - Myakka City
- CountyManatee
- Subdivision Waterbury Tracts Continued
Overview
Welcome to a one-of-a-kind 5-acre estate in the heart of Myakka City, offering the perfect blend of country charm, income potential, and multigenerational living. This unique property features multiple structures and incredible versatility. The main residence is a character-filled 2-bedroom, 3-bathroom home with a custom design and timeless appeal. Step inside through an extraordinary 200-year-old wooden front door and into a spacious living area featuring soaring ceilings, a stunning custom fireplace, and rich wood floors. The open dining area flows seamlessly into the kitchen, with additional storage tucked under the stairwell. A large sunroom with its own entrance has long been a thriving sanctuary for indoor plants and adds to the home's charm. Upstairs, you'll find a generously sized primary suite with a private balcony, an expansive walk-in closet, and master bath featuring his-and-hers vanities and a walk-in shower. A second upstairs bedroom includes its own closet, and the adjacent bathroom offers a tub/shower. There is also an open loft area perfect for a home office or additional living space, as well as a long linen closet for added storage. Downstairs, a back entry leads into a functional laundry/mudroom and a full bathroom. There is also a spacious game room complete with its own sink and countertop area, ideal for entertaining. Additional conveniences include a central vacuum system, custom wood features, and thoughtful storage throughout. Beyond the main home, the detached two-story barn-style building adds even more potential. The ground floor includes a studio apartment with a private entrance, while the second floor offers a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment, also with a private entrance. There is also workshop or storage space on the ground floor. Nearby, a charming cabin provides yet more potential as it has power, water, and its own bathroom. A large pole barn with water and electric offers flexible use for livestock, equipment, or outdoor gatherings. The property is cross-fenced and includes a front pasture, making it ideal for horses, livestock, or agricultural use. A private well, irrigation system, and chain-link perimeter fencing add convenience and peace of mind. Whether you're looking for a peaceful country retreat, a multigenerational homestead, or an income-producing property, this special Myakka City estate offers room to grow, live, and create.
Agriculture / Farm
Association Fees / Info
Senior Community: No
Association: ,No,
Bathroom Info
Total Baths: 4.00
Fullbaths: 4
Building Info
Roof: Metal, Shingle
Building Area Source: PublicRecords
Buyer Compensation
Exterior Features
Patio: FrontPorch, SidePorch, Balcony
Pool Private: No
Exterior Features: Balcony, SprinklerIrrigation, Storage
Fees / Restrictions
Financial
Original Price: $850,000
Fencing: ChainLink
Garage / Parking
Open Parking: No
Attached Garage: No
Garage: No
Carport: No
Green / Env Info
Interior Features
Fireplace Desc: LivingRoom
Fireplace: Yes
Floors: Wood
Levels: Two
Spa: No
Laundry Features: Inside
Interior Features: CeilingFans, HighCeilings, Loft
Appliances: ConvectionOven, Cooktop, Dryer, Refrigerator, Washer
Lot Info
Direction Remarks: From Verna Bethany and SR 64, take Verna Bethany South, turn right on L&J Rd, turn left on 257th St. E., property is at the end of the road on the right.
Lot Size Units: Acres
Lot Size Acres: 5
Lot Sqft: 217,800
Lot Desc: OversizedLot, Pasture
Misc
Other
Other Structures: Barns, GuestHouse, Sheds, Storage
Special Conditions: None
Other Rooms Info
Property Info
Section: 11
Class Type: SingleFamilyResidence
Property Sub Type: SingleFamilyResidence
Property Condition: NewConstruction
Property Attached: No
New Construction: No
Construction Materials: WoodFrame
Stories: 2
Total Stories: 2
Foundation: Slab
Human Modified: Yes
Room Info
Total Rooms: 8
Sqft Info
Sqft: 3,304
Bulding Area Sqft: 4,847
Living Area Units: SquareFeet
Living Area Source: PublicRecords
Tax Info
Tax Year: 2,024
Tax Lot: V026
Tax Legal Description: COM AT CONC MON MARK SE COR OF SW1/4 OF SEC 11; TH N 00 DEG 02 MIN 42 SEC W ALG E LN OF SD SW1/4, 1323.38 FT TO A CONC MON MARK SE COR OF NE1/4 OF SD SW1/4 FOR A POB; TH CONT N 00 DEG 02 MIN 42 SEC W 310.84 FT; TH N 89 DEG 48 MIN 07 SEC W PARALLEL TO N LN OF TRACT 21 WATERBURY GRAPEFRUIT TRACTS (PB 2 P 37) & 20 FT SLY THEREFROM 705.45 FT; TH S 00 DEG 02 MIN
Tax Block: 1015
Tax Annual Amount: 9289.87
Tax Book Number: 2-37
Unit Info
Utilities / Hvac
Heating: Central
Water Source: Well
Sewer: SepticTank
Cool System: CentralAir, CeilingFans
Cooling: Yes
Heating: Yes
Utilities: ElectricityConnected, Propane
Waterfront / Water
Waterfront: No
View: Yes
View: TreesWoods
Directions
From Verna Bethany and SR 64, take Verna Bethany South, turn right on L&J Rd, turn left on 257th St. E., property is at the end of the road on the right.This listing courtesy of Harry Robbins Assoc Inc
The information being provided by © 2025 My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS is for the consumer's
personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to
identify prospective properties consumer may be interested in purchasing. Any information relating
to real estate for sale referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX)
program of the My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS. XCELLENCE REALTY, INC is not a Multiple Listing Service (MLS), nor does it offer MLS access. This website is a service of XCELLENCE REALTY, INC, a broker participant of My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site.
MLS IDX data last updated on 07-23-2025 2:02 AM EST.
If you have any questions on 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida, please call David Shippey at 863-521-4517.
MLS# A4655682 located at 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida is brought to you by David Shippey REALTOR®
5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida has 6 Beds, 4 Full Bath, and 0 Half Bath.
The MLS Number for 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida is A4655682.
The price for 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida is $799,000.
The status of 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida is Active.
The subdivision of 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida is Waterbury Tracts Continued.
The home located at 5034 257th Street, Myakka, Florida was built in 2025.
Related Searches: Chain of Lakes Winter Haven Florida