To schedule a showing of 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida, Call David Shippey at 863-521-4517 TODAY!

$499,900 Reduced -$40,100
4158 Prudence Drive
Sarasota, FL 34235
  • 4Beds
  • 3.00Total Baths
  • 3 Full, 0 HalfBaths
  • 2,573SqFt
  • 1967Year Built
  • 0.28Acres
  • MLS# A4689465
  • Residential
  • SingleFamilyResidence
  • Pending

  • Approx Time on Market1 month, 30 days
  • Area34235 - Sarasota
  • CountySarasota
  • Subdivision Kensington Park

Overview

Under contract-accepting backup offers. Located in the established Kensington Park community, this beautifully updated four-bedroom, three-bath residence with a pool offers a thoughtfully designed single-level layout with a desirable split-bedroom floor plan, creating a seamless balance of privacy and open-concept living. Spacious living and dining areas flow effortlessly, making the home ideal for both everyday comfort and entertaining.The upscale kitchen, features a large island with dual sinks, ample cabinetry, stainless appliances, and generous counter space, perfectly suited for meal preparation, casual dining, and hosting gatherings. Multiple living areas enhance the homes versatility, while a substantial bonus room with a working fireplace provides added flexibility for a media room, or additional living space.The large primary suite features dual vanities, a steam shower with double shower heads, soaking tub and full walk-in closet. Wheelchair accessibility adds to the homes overall convenience. The split floorpan offers three more bedrooms with two full bathrooms and a private office. Outdoor living is elevated by a fully fenced backyard with mature landscaping and a private pool, complete with an updated system and prior refinishing. A double gate allows for boat or additional storage access. The property also includes a two-car garage with a newly resurfaced floor and ample additional parking.Recent updates provide peace of mind, including a 2019 renovation with updated electrical and plumbing systems, a new roof (2025), new water heater (2025), and a 2019 HVAC system with UV filtration. Hurricane-impact windows and doors are installed. The exterior has been freshly painted, and additional features include buried electrical in the backyard for a future shed, included appliances, and a home warranty with approximately four years remaining covering major components.Kensington Park is ideally located in the heart of Sarasota, just minutes from The Mall at University Town Center, offering a wide selection of shopping, dining, and entertainment. The home is also conveniently close to downtown Sarasota, Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, and the areas renowned Gulf beaches, including Lido Key and Siesta Key. With easy access to major roadways, parks, and everyday conveniences, this location offers both accessibility and the best of the Sarasota lifestyle.



Agriculture / Farm

Association Fees / Info

Community Features:  Sidewalks

Pets Allowed:  CatsOk, DogsOk

Bathroom Info

Total Baths:  3.00

Fullbaths:  3

Building Info

Window Features:  Blinds, WindowTreatments

Roof:  Shingle

Building Area Source:  PublicRecords

Buyer Compensation

Exterior Features

Style:  Custom

Pool Features:  InGround, PoolSweep

Patio:  Covered, Patio

Pool Private:  Yes

Fees / Restrictions

Financial

Original Price:  $540,000

Fencing:  Vinyl

Garage / Parking

Attached Garage:  Yes

Garage:  Yes

Green / Env Info

Interior Features

Fireplace Desc:  WoodBurning

Fireplace:  Yes

Floors:  Carpet, CeramicTile

Levels:  One

Laundry Features:  WasherHookup, Inside, LaundryRoom

Interior Features:  CeilingFans, MainLevelPrimary, WindowTreatments

Appliances:  Dryer, Dishwasher, ExhaustFan, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Washer

Spa Features:  InGround

Lot Info

Direction Remarks:  Head east on Fruitville Rd, turn right onto Beneva Rd, then left onto 17th St, and finally left onto Prudence Dr to reach 4158 Prudence Dr (property will be on your right).

Lot Size Units:  Acres

Lot Size Acres:  0.28

Lot Sqft:  12,346

Vegetation:  PartiallyWooded

Lot Desc:  Landscaped

Misc

Other

Special Conditions:  None

Other Rooms Info

Property Info

Section:  15

Class Type:  SingleFamilyResidence

Property Sub Type:  SingleFamilyResidence

Property Condition:  NewConstruction

Construction Materials:  Brick, Block

Stories:  1

Total Stories:  1

Foundation:  Block

Human Modified:  Yes

Room Info

Total Rooms:  9

Sqft Info

Sqft:  2,573

Bulding Area Sqft:  3,317

Living Area Units:  SquareFeet

Living Area Source:  PublicRecords

Tax Info

Tax Year:  2,025

Tax Lot:  1113

Tax Legal Description:  LOT 1113 KENSINGTON PARK UNIT 9

Tax Annual Amount:  5244.08

Tax Book Number:  17-48

Unit Info

Utilities / Hvac

Heating:  Electric

Water Source:  None

Sewer:  PublicSewer

Cool System:  CentralAir, CeilingFans

Cooling:  Yes

Heating:  Yes

Utilities:  CableAvailable, ElectricityAvailable, MunicipalUtilities, SewerAvailable, WaterAvailable, WaterNotAvailable

Waterfront / Water

Schools

Elem:  Gocio Elementary

Middle:  Booker Middle

High:  Booker High

Directions

Head east on Fruitville Rd, turn right onto Beneva Rd, then left onto 17th St, and finally left onto Prudence Dr to reach 4158 Prudence Dr (property will be on your right).

This listing courtesy of Re/max Alliance Group 

Mortgage Calculator

%
$
%
Dollars per $1000
$
Approximate Monthly Payment 0.0
Price & Status History (on davidshippey.com since Sat, Apr 11th 2026)
  • Original Price: $540,000
  • Current Price: $499,900
  • Price Reduced: $40,100
Date ChangedFromTo
05/16/2026ActivePending
05/04/2026$540,000 $499,900 Reduced by $40,100

Broker Reciprocity The information being provided by © 2026 My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS is for the consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumer may be interested in purchasing. Any information relating to real estate for sale referenced on this web site comes from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS. XCELLENCE is not a Multiple Listing Service (MLS), nor does it offer MLS access. This website is a service of XCELLENCE, a broker participant of My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS. This web site may reference real estate listing(s) held by a brokerage firm other than the broker and/or agent who owns this web site. MLS IDX data last updated on 06-10-2026 8:43 AM EST.

Any images related to data from the MLS is the sole property of the MLS and not the responsibility of the owner of this website. This real estate website and IDX data is hosted by IDX data is Powered & Hosted by Dynamic IDX, LLC Real Estate Web Solutions

If you have any questions on 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida, please call David Shippey at 863-521-4517.


MLS# A4689465 located at 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida is brought to you by David Shippey REALTOR®

4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida has 4 Beds, 3 Full Bath, and 0 Half Bath.
The MLS Number for 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida is A4689465.
The price for 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida is $499,900.
The status of 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida is Pending.
The subdivision of 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida is Kensington Park.
The home located at 4158 Prudence Drive, Sarasota, Florida was built in 2026.